Now maybe you don't think that is bad, but he had entered it into a contest and called it a "pure" picture. So my main question is, is what he did considered cheating? Does it make a difference if you know that the judges of the contest didn't catch the photoshoping in the photo, someone else had to point it out to them?
So what is the line between right and wrong? Should he have his title stripped? Or do you think it is no big deal like Byrne who said that everyone "messes with their photos" and thought the taking of his title was unjusified? What would you say if you were a judge that was mis-informed?